Across the full original-brief inventory, the no-think ladder was non-decreasing and text-rung failures remained substantial; per-turn thinking did not repair the raw transcript under the underspecified brief, while directive and enforcement performance converged at stronger models.

Reported and observed measurements

Assessments (0)

No immutable Assessment has been published for this Claim yet.

Runs (0)

No execution has been linked to this Claim yet.

Each row is a measurement with its reported value, latest available observation, and cumulative evidence state.
Metric and conditions	Reported	Latest observation	Evidence judgment
arm: raw transcript · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 16 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128	0.12 proportion	—	Not assessed
arm: text checklist · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 45 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128	0.35 proportion	—	Not assessed
arm: directive gate · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 90 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128	0.7 proportion	—	Not assessed
arm: enforcement gate · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 127 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128	0.99 proportion	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: raw transcript to text checklist · reasoning: no-think	0 p-value	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: raw transcript to text checklist · reasoning: no-think	0.0003 p-value	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: text checklist to directive gate · reasoning: no-think	0 p-value	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: text checklist to directive gate · reasoning: no-think	0 p-value	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: directive gate to enforcement gate · reasoning: no-think	0 p-value	—	Not assessed
brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: directive gate to enforcement gate · reasoning: no-think	0 p-value	—	Not assessed
arm: raw transcript · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 2 · reasoning: thinking · denominator: 68	0.03 proportion	—	Not assessed
arm: text checklist · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 4 · reasoning: thinking · denominator: 19	0.21 proportion	—	Not assessed

Metric and conditions

Reported

Latest observation

Evidence judgment

arm: raw transcript · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 16 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128

0.12 proportion

—

Not assessed

arm: text checklist · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 45 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128

0.35 proportion

—

Not assessed

arm: directive gate · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 90 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128

0.7 proportion

—

Not assessed

arm: enforcement gate · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 127 · reasoning: no-think · denominator: 128

0.99 proportion

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: raw transcript to text checklist · reasoning: no-think

0 p-value

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: raw transcript to text checklist · reasoning: no-think

0.0003 p-value

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: text checklist to directive gate · reasoning: no-think

0 p-value

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: text checklist to directive gate · reasoning: no-think

0 p-value

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: directive gate to enforcement gate · reasoning: no-think

0 p-value

—

Not assessed

brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · contrast: directive gate to enforcement gate · reasoning: no-think

0 p-value

—

Not assessed

arm: raw transcript · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 2 · reasoning: thinking · denominator: 68

0.03 proportion

—

Not assessed

arm: text checklist · brief: original · model: Qwen3.6-35B · steps: 15 · density: 0.3 · scoring: primary · numerator: 4 · reasoning: thinking · denominator: 19

0.21 proportion

—

Not assessed

Reported and observed measurements

Assessments (0)

Runs (0)

Measurement results