The PACIFIC 7B component ablation separates the reward roles: retaining CIG but removing the asymmetric bonus yields useful post-clarification answers but low clarification recall; retaining the asymmetric bonus but removing CIG largely preserves recall while reducing post-clarification F1. Removing both performs worst overall among the four variants.

The PACIFIC 7B component ablation separates the reward roles: retaining CIG but removing the asymmetric bonus yields useful post-clarification answers but low clarification recall; retaining the asymmetric bonus but removing CIG largely preserves recall while reducing post-clarification F1. Removing both performs worst overall among the four variants. · CiteArk

Measurement results

0/16 assessed

0 supported0 disputed or conflicting16 not assessed

The complete result group stays with its claim. Assessed rows come first; their judgments do not replace the whole-claim conclusion. Expand a row for conditions, sources, and evidence history.

Each row is a measurement with its reported value, latest available observation, and cumulative evidence state.
Metric and conditions	Reported	Latest observation	Evidence judgment
CIG: true · variant: CIGAsk 7B · asymmetricBonus: true	0.795 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: CIGAsk 7B · asymmetricBonus: true	0.768 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: CIGAsk 7B · asymmetricBonus: true	0.873 proportion	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: CIGAsk 7B · asymmetricBonus: true	0.26 proportion	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: -asym · asymmetricBonus: false	0.736 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: -asym · asymmetricBonus: false	0.733 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: -asym · asymmetricBonus: false	0.171 proportion	—	Not assessed
CIG: true · variant: -asym · asymmetricBonus: false	0.036 proportion	—	Not assessed
CIG: false · variant: -CIG · asymmetricBonus: true	0.744 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: false · variant: -CIG · asymmetricBonus: true	0.7 score (0-1)	—	Not assessed
CIG: false · variant: -CIG · asymmetricBonus: true	0.763 proportion	—	Not assessed
CIG: false · variant: -CIG · asymmetricBonus: true	0.167 proportion	—	Not assessed

Reported and observed measurements

Assessments (0)

Runs (0)

Measurement results